Trucking companies exposed to new liability risk after FMCSA preemption Jan10


Related Posts

Share This

Trucking companies exposed to new liability risk after FMCSA preemption

The Teamsters want the court to reverse the federal agency’s ruling, claiming that it harms union-represented drivers who work for companies that have been providing paid meal periods and rest breaks under California law. and prohibit drivers from operating a truck if a driver feels too tired to drive safely. California’s meal and rest break laws require drivers be given a 30-minute meal break every five hours and an additional 10-minute rest break every four hours. (ATA) and others, asserting that having a uniform rule addressing rest breaks increases safety.
However, “the suggestion that California’s meal and rest break rules negatively impact highway safety is ludicrous,” the Teamsters countered in response to the decision.“The idea that providing a 10-minute rest break after four hours and a 30-minute meal break after five hours somehow makes the roads less safe is beyond comprehension. “However, carriers should understand that, until the challenge to the FMCSA determination is resolved, there is some risk for carriers that elect to stop complying with California’s meal and rest break laws.
If the FMCSA decision is vacated, those carriers risk accruing a liability for violations during the gap period between reliance on FMCSA’s determination and a court’s reversal.”Sharma said carriers have had to design driver routes and schedules to allow drivers to take meal and rest breaks as prescribed by California law, “which cuts into the amount of productive work time they otherwise would have had under the federal HOS rules.”The ATA contends that because the Ninth Circuit has never ruled on whether the state’s meal and rest break requirements are preempted under the federal statute on which FMCSA’s decision was based, “we are confident that the Ninth Circuit will not second-guess a decision that Congress expressly delegated to the agency with responsibility for, and expertise in, [commercial motor vehicle] safety nationwide,” the association told FreightWaves in a statement.
The group noted that the Ninth Circuit did rule previously that the meal and rest break requirements are not preempted, but it was under a statute preempting state laws relating to a motor carrier’s prices, routes, or services, and not under FMCSA’s safety mandate.ATA also pointed out that while California’s regulations have already produced a number of class action lawsuits by truckers claiming their company has not allowed them to take their 30-minute break after five hours, “it is our belief those suits are now moot” because of the FMCSA’s ruling., which represents independent truckers, has been “open to a more limited and balanced approach” than ATA in addressing the issue, and asserted that FMCSA’s preemption “further complicates an already complex issue,” Todd Spencer, the association’s president, said in statement.“We agree with many other industry stakeholders that certain federal statutes need to be reviewed, but any changes should be thoroughly vetted to make sure it’s done right. We think FMCSA’s decision may generate legal challenges and it remains to be seen how state lawmakers in California respond to a federal preemption that effectively guts state labor laws designed to protect employee truck drivers,” Spencer said. Despite its jurisdictional focus on safety, the FMCSA in its decision highlighted comments from carriers that were concerned about the operational and financial implications of the California law as well.) explained, for example, that in order to take off-duty breaks, “drivers must slow down, exit the roadway, find a safe and suitable location to park and secure their vehicles, and then exit the vehicle.” The company, therefore, has to build into the drivers’ routes up to 90 minutes of additional time.

Call or Click to get 50% OFF for the First Month
24/7 Dispatching Service 888-852-4238


Protected by Copyscape Plagiarism Software
Load Board


Post, Search & Bid on UNLIMITED truck loads
Over 30,000 new loads NO DUPLICATES. Sort by combination of weight, trailer, radius & multiple destinations. Easy to use!
g Owner Operator & Truck Driver Search
Great for Shippers & Brokers! Search Drivers by trailer type and any location. Get Freight Quotes directly from drivers by email.
No Contract Month-to-Month Billing
We have 100% no questions asked Money Back Guarantee policy. You can cancel and renew your membership at anytime.
Mileage & Routing Directions
Calculate dead head miles and total miles of trips. Intergrated Map with US Highways and dirving directions from pickup to deivery.
Credit Score Reports & Factoring
Freight Broker credit score search. Invoice matched with Freight Factoring companies.
Dead Head Mileage Calculator
Calculate dead head miles between trips. Radius search for loads within dead head mile limit.
Bookmark, Notes and Favorites
Easily manage your dispatching services with Bookmarking important shippers or drivers, with custom notes.
Load & Driver Email Notifications
Receive email or SMS alerts of loads or owner operations that match your posted loads or trailer types.
Auto Match Loads & Drivers
After you post your Open Truck or Open Load on the load board you will automatically be matached with drivers or shippers.
Send Load Details to Phone SMS Message
Great for dispatchers! allows for drivers to get info while driving and not stop on the raod. Easy to call back from phone.
Daily Fuel Prices & Locations
Daily current diesel fuel prices at all major truck stop locations.
Upload Forms: Cargo Insurance, W-9, & Permits
Great for dispatching! have all your driver's paperwork ready in one location. Documents can be faxed or uploaded as files.
How To Videos Guides
Step by step video tutorials on how to use all the features of the admin to find loads, find drivers and other resources.
Weather & Road Conditions
Live weather forcast from pickup location and destination. View Current and weekly forecast.